Dairyland has insured drivers other companies avoid for more than 70 years, and it has a niche most non-standard insurers don’t: motorcycles and off-road vehicles. It is also a rare case where a high-risk specialist has a better-than-average complaint record. This 2026 update replaces our older review with regulator complaint data from Texas and California and the details Dairyland publishes today.
This review is for educational purposes only and is not personalized insurance advice. We are not licensed insurance agents. Coverage, discounts and availability vary by state; your policy documents control.
The Verdict
One of the strongest non-standard auto insurers on complaint data, and a specialist for motorcycles and recreational vehicles. If you need an SR-22, have a lapse or violation, or ride, Dairyland belongs on your quote list. With a clean record, compare it against standard carriers too.
| Parent | Sentry Insurance Group, Stevens Point, Wisconsin |
| Financial strength | Sentry: AM Best A+ (Superior), per Dairyland’s site |
| Auto since / motorcycle since | 1953 / 1966 |
| Products | Auto, motorcycle, ATV/UTV, snowmobile, dirt bike, scooter/moped; Mexico auto, RV and renters through other insurers |
| Filings | SR-22 and FR-44 |
| Texas complaint index, 2025 | 0.41 (Dairyland County Mutual; 1.00 is average) |
| California complaint ratio, 2025 | 0.9 per 100,000 (Viking Insurance Co. of Wisconsin), 7th of 50; median 3.15 |
What Dairyland Covers
Auto
Dairyland’s auto page pitches to drivers with “a lapse in coverage, a violation on your record, or a foreign license,” as well as senior and new drivers. It says it is “well-versed in SR-22 and FR-44 certificates, as well as insurance for drivers with DUIs and other violations,” and offers “flexible payment plans, low down payments.” Coverages include bodily injury liability, collision, comprehensive and uninsured/underinsured motorist. Named discounts include multi-car, advanced quote, defensive driver course and paying in full or quarterly; it does not publish percentages, and “available discounts will vary by state.”
Motorcycle
Motorcycles are where Dairyland stands apart. Its motorcycle page says “since 1966, riders have chosen Dairyland insurance to help protect their motorcycles,” and lists:
- Standard: bodily injury liability, property damage liability, guest passenger liability, collision, comprehensive
- Optional: special equipment, replacement cost, roadside assistance, rental reimbursement
- Discounts: multi-cycle, Harley Owners Group (H.O.G.) member and home ownership
It also insures ATVs and UTVs, snowmobiles, dirt bikes and scooters/mopeds. For what riders typically pay, see our guide to the average cost of motorcycle insurance.
Who Underwrites It
Dairyland’s underwriting companies page says its coverages are written by “members of the Sentry Insurance Group, Stevens Point, WI,” and lists Sentry Insurance Company, Dairyland County Mutual Insurance Company of Texas (Texas only), Dairyland Insurance Company, Dairyland National Insurance Company, Middlesex Insurance Company, Patriot General Insurance Company, Peak Property and Casualty Insurance Corporation and Viking Insurance Company of Wisconsin.
One more detail matters for reading the complaint data below. Sentry companies also write The General’s policies: The General’s legal disclosures say its coverage is underwritten by a member of the Sentry Insurance Group, which in Texas is Dairyland County Mutual and in California is Viking. So those two companies’ figures cover The General’s policies as well as Dairyland-branded ones.
Complaint Record
Texas
In the Texas Department of Insurance’s complaint index dataset, Dairyland County Mutual Insurance Company of Texas had 5 confirmed complaints on 73,668 auto policies in 2025, an index of 0.41, improved from 0.73 (6 on 77,093) in 2024. That is the best result among the non-standard insurers we review, and it improved while Texas auto complaints overall rose 55.6%.
Dairyland County Mutual beside other non-standard insurers we review
California
Viking Insurance Company of Wisconsin ranks 7th of the 50 largest auto insurers in California’s 2026 Consumer Complaint Study: 3 justified complaints in 2025 on about 338,883 exposures, a ratio of 0.9 per 100,000. It has been well below the median in all three years of the study.
Viking Insurance Company of Wisconsin vs. the median of the 50 largest auto insurers
Full tables: Texas car insurance complaint index and California car insurance complaint ratios.
Drawbacks
- Not built for clean-record discounts. Non-standard insurers price for higher risk. A driver with a clean record will often find lower premiums with a preferred-market carrier; our best car insurance ranking scores six of them.
- Some products are not Dairyland’s own. Its site says Mexico auto, RV and renters offerings “are not underwritten by Dairyland Insurance Company or its affiliates.”
- Discounts are not published. You will only see what you qualify for on a quote.
- Availability varies. Dairyland says coverage availability, terms, limits and exclusions vary by state.
Who Dairyland Suits
- Drivers who need an SR-22 or FR-44, have a lapse or violations, or hold a foreign license
- Riders who want motorcycle, off-road or snowmobile coverage from a specialist
- Anyone in the non-standard market who wants a below-average complaint record
Compare it with other non-standard insurers before you buy: we review National General, Infinity (Kemper Auto), GoAuto and Fred Loya. And if you are unsure what a filing means, see what SR-22 insurance is.
FAQ
Is Dairyland a good insurance company?
On regulator complaint data it is one of the better non-standard auto insurers. Dairyland County Mutual Insurance Company of Texas had a 2025 Texas auto complaint index of 0.41, where 1.00 is average, and Viking Insurance Company of Wisconsin, one of Dairyland’s underwriters, ranked 7th of California’s 50 largest auto insurers with 0.9 justified complaints per 100,000 exposures. Sentry, Dairyland’s group, has an AM Best rating of A+ (Superior).
Is Dairyland good for motorcycle insurance?
Dairyland says riders have chosen it since 1966. Its motorcycle policies list bodily injury and property damage liability, guest passenger liability, collision and comprehensive, with optional special equipment, replacement cost, roadside assistance and rental reimbursement, plus multi-cycle, Harley Owners Group member and home ownership discounts. It does not publish discount percentages.
Does Dairyland do SR-22 insurance?
Yes. Dairyland’s auto page says it is “well-versed in SR-22 and FR-44 certificates, as well as insurance for drivers with DUIs and other violations.”
Who owns Dairyland Insurance?
Dairyland is part of the Sentry Insurance Group of Stevens Point, Wisconsin. Its website says Dairyland coverages are underwritten by member companies of the group, including Dairyland Insurance Company, Dairyland County Mutual Insurance Company of Texas, Viking Insurance Company of Wisconsin and Peak Property and Casualty Insurance Corporation.
