● INDEPENDENT  ·  NO CARRIER OWNS US  ·  READER-FUNDED
MethodologyNewsletterMON · NOV 16, 2026

GEICO Review 2026: Market Share, Complaint Data and What It Actually Sells

GEICO is the No. 3 U.S. auto insurer, with an 84.7% combined ratio in 2025. Its Texas and California complaint data, and policies it sells but doesn't write.

GEICO is one of the most recognized names in American insurance, and one of the cheapest to run: it sells mostly direct, online and by phone, without paying agent commissions. This 2026 update replaces our older review with GEICO’s own numbers from Berkshire Hathaway’s annual report and complaint data from the Texas and California insurance departments. Two things stand out since we last wrote about it: GEICO is no longer No. 2 by market share, and it is earning billions of dollars a year in underwriting profit.

This review is for educational purposes only and is not personalized insurance advice. We are not licensed insurance agents. Coverage, rates and complaint data vary by state and change over time.

The Verdict

A strong, low-cost default for drivers comfortable buying direct, with a below-average complaint record in the data we checked. It is less of a one-stop shop than its advertising suggests: home, renters and life policies sold under the GEICO name are written by other companies. For how GEICO compares with five other national carriers on price, claims satisfaction, coverage and digital tools, see our best car insurance ranking.

OwnerBerkshire Hathaway
Market position3rd-largest U.S. private passenger auto insurer, ~11.6% share (A.M. Best, 2024 data)
2025 premiums written$45.2 billion
2025 combined ratio84.7% (loss ratio 72.3% + expense ratio 12.4%)
WhereAll 50 states and D.C.
How it sellsMainly direct (online and phone), some agencies
Texas complaint index, 20250.76 combined across GEICO-named companies (1.00 is average)
California complaint ratio, 2025GEICO General 2.0 per 100,000; GEICO Indemnity and GEICO Protection 0.0; median 3.15

Who GEICO Is Now

Berkshire Hathaway’s 2025 annual report says GEICO’s insurance subsidiaries, which “include Government Employees Insurance Company and several other insurance entities,” sell private passenger auto insurance “in all 50 states and the District of Columbia.” Key points from the report:

  • Market share. “According to the A.M. Best data for 2024 published in 2025, the five largest private passenger automobile insurers had a combined market share of approximately 63.6% based on written premiums, with GEICO’s market share being the third largest at approximately 11.6%.” Our earlier review called GEICO No. 2; that is out of date.
  • What GEICO writes itself: private passenger auto, plus motorcycles, ATVs, RVs, boats and commercial vehicles, “primarily through direct response methods.”
  • What it sells but does not write: GEICO “operates an insurance agency that offers insurance written by third parties” for coverages it does not sell itself, “such as homeowners, renters, condominium, life and identity protection insurance.”
  • Claims: GEICO “primarily uses its own claims staff to manage and settle claims.”

That last distinction matters if you bundle. A GEICO home policy may be written by a different insurer with its own claims process and complaint record. Ask which company issues it.

Underwriting Results

GEICO underwriting results

Combined ratio (losses + expenses ÷ premiums earned)

0% 25% 50% 75% 100% 81.0% 9.7% 2023 71.8% 9.7% 2024 72.3% 12.4% 2025 Loss & LAE ratio Expense ratio
Loss and loss adjustment expense ratio and underwriting expense ratio, as a share of premiums earned. Combined ratio: 90.7% (2023), 81.5% (2024), 84.7% (2025). Source: Berkshire Hathaway 2025 Form 10-K.

GEICO earned $6.8 billion of pre-tax underwriting profit in 2025 on $44.5 billion of premiums earned, after $7.8 billion in 2024. Berkshire attributes 2025’s premium growth “primarily” to “an increase in policies-in-force,” after policies in force fell 0.5% in 2024. The underwriting expense ratio rose from 9.7% to 12.4%. A combined ratio well under 100% is a sign of financial health, not a promise of lower prices for any individual driver.

Complaint Record

Texas

The Texas Department of Insurance complaint index dataset lists eight auto companies with GEICO or Government Employees in the name. Together they had 167 confirmed complaints on 1,330,808 policies in 2025, a combined index of 0.76 (our calculation; 1.00 is average), up from 0.50 in 2024. GEICO Texas County Mutual, the largest at 855,054 policies, was at 0.60; GEICO County Mutual, at 1.36, was the only GEICO company with 10,000+ policies above average.

Regulator complaint data, 2025

GEICO companies in Texas (index, 1.00 = average)

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 GEICO Indemnity 0.09 GEICO Advantage 0.42 GEICO Texas County Mutual 0.60 Government Employees 0.68 GEICO County Mutual 1.36 All 8 GEICO-named, combined 0.76 1.00 = average
Texas Department of Insurance complaint index, auto, 2025; companies with 10,000+ policies plus the combined figure for all eight GEICO-named companies (our calculation). Source: TDI complaint indexes and policy counts, downloaded October 28, 2026.

California

California’s 2026 Consumer Complaint Study includes three GEICO companies among the 50 largest auto insurers:

CompanyApprox. exposuresJustified complaints 2025Ratio 2025 (per 100,000)Ratio 2024Rank of 50
GEICO Indemnity Company167,49800.04.62
GEICO Protection Insurance Company57,34400.00.04
GEICO General Insurance Company3,456,991682.02.016

GEICO General is the second-largest auto insurer in the study by exposures, behind State Farm Mutual (3.1), and is well below the 3.15 median. Full tables: Texas car insurance complaint index and California car insurance complaint ratios.

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Low operating costs from direct selling, and a strong recent underwriting record
  • Below-average complaint indexes in Texas and California, including zero justified complaints at two California companies
  • Available in every state, with its own claims staff
  • Writes motorcycles, ATVs, RVs and boats as well as cars

Cons

  • Its Texas complaint index rose from 0.50 to 0.76 in 2025, and GEICO County Mutual is above average
  • Home, renters, condo and life policies sold under the GEICO name are written by other companies
  • Buying direct means no agent reviewing your coverage gaps; our guide to how much car insurance you need covers the basics

Who GEICO Suits

GEICO fits drivers who want to buy and manage a policy themselves, value a low-cost insurer with a clean complaint record, and mainly need auto coverage. If you are bundling auto with home, compare the GEICO-sold home policy’s actual insurer, or look at our guide to bundling home and auto insurance. For a head-to-head with the other national brands, see GEICO vs. Allstate vs. State Farm vs. Progressive.

FAQ

Is GEICO the second-largest auto insurer?

Not anymore. Berkshire Hathaway’s 2025 annual report, citing A.M. Best data for 2024, says GEICO’s market share was the third largest among private passenger auto insurers, at approximately 11.6% of written premiums.

Does GEICO sell homeowners insurance?

GEICO sells homeowners, renters, condo, life and identity protection coverage through its insurance agency, but those policies are written by third-party insurers, according to Berkshire Hathaway’s 2025 annual report. GEICO’s own insurance companies write auto, motorcycle, ATV, RV, boat and commercial vehicle policies.

Does GEICO have a lot of complaints?

Fewer than average for its size in the two state datasets we analyzed. In Texas, the eight GEICO-named companies had a combined 2025 auto complaint index of 0.76, where 1.00 is average, though that rose from 0.50 in 2024. In California, GEICO General Insurance Company had 2.0 justified complaints per 100,000 exposures in 2025, against a median of 3.15 for the 50 largest auto insurers, and two other GEICO companies had none.

Who owns GEICO?

Berkshire Hathaway. Its annual report describes GEICO’s insurance subsidiaries, including Government Employees Insurance Company, as writing private passenger auto insurance in all 50 states and the District of Columbia, mainly through direct response methods.

Alejandro Rioja

Alejandro Rioja

Founder & Lead Analyst · The Insurance Nerd

Alejandro has spent six years dismantling insurance jargon for everyday readers. He built the Nerd Score to give people a single, honest number they can actually trust — with the math published in full and not a dollar taken from the carriers it ranks.

Field Notes

One sharp insurance read, every Thursday.

The Nerd Desk newsletter: a single number, one carrier move worth knowing, and the fine print we caught this week. Free. No spam, ever.

UNSUBSCRIBE ANYTIME