● INDEPENDENT  ·  NO CARRIER OWNS US  ·  READER-FUNDED
MethodologyNewsletterMON · NOV 16, 2026

Fred Loya Insurance Review 2026: Complaint Data, Coverage and Who It Suits

Fred Loya sells low-cost auto insurance from 800+ offices in 13 states. Regulator data puts its insurers near the bottom on complaints in Texas and California.

Fred Loya Insurance is one of the few auto insurers built around drivers that standard carriers decline or price out: people who need an SR-22, have a DUI or a lapse in coverage, or simply need the cheapest legal policy. Its storefronts are everywhere in the Southwest. The question this review answers is what you give up for that access, using the complaint data that Texas and California regulators publish.

This review is for educational purposes only and is not personalized insurance advice. We are not licensed insurance agents. Coverage, pricing and availability vary by state; your policy documents control.

The Verdict

Accessible and widely available, with one of the weakest regulator complaint records of any large auto insurer we track. Fred Loya can make sense if you need minimum coverage fast and have been turned away elsewhere. Get at least two other non-standard quotes first.

Founded1974, El Paso, Texas, by Fred Loya Sr.
Footprint13 states listed on its website; “over 800 offices”
Typical policySix-month, low-limit liability and low-value physical damage (per a California exam report)
How it sellsCaptive offices, including Walmart Supercenters in 10 states; phone
Texas complaint index, 20257.78 (Loya Insurance Company; 1.00 is average)
California complaint ratio, 202517.8 per 100,000 exposures (Loya Casualty), 45th of 50; median 3.15

Who Is Behind a Fred Loya Policy

Fred Loya’s About page says the company “started with a single store front in El Paso Texas in 1974” and has “expanded to over 12 states, 800 offices and over 3500 employees,” with offices “at Walmart Supercenters in 10 states.” Its home page lists 13 states: Arizona, California, Colorado, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Texas, Indiana, Tennessee, Georgia, Illinois, Nevada, Alabama and Ohio.

The agency sells policies issued by companies in the Loya Insurance Group. A California Department of Insurance examination report on Loya Casualty Insurance Company spells out the structure:

  • The exam was coordinated with Texas as lead state of Loya Insurance Group, alongside its Texas-domiciled companies Loya Insurance Company, Vision Insurance Company and Young America Insurance Company.
  • The group’s ultimate parent is EP Loya Group, LP.
  • Loya Casualty “writes six-month policies for low limits of liability automobile insurance and low-value property damage automobile insurance,” and its products “are produced solely by FLI [Fred Loya Insurance Agency, Inc.] through captive agency offices.”
  • Loya Casualty wrote $163.8 million of direct premium in 2022 and reported net underwriting losses in 2021, 2022 and 2023, which the report attributes partly to attorney-represented bodily injury claims and inflation in repair costs.

Complaint Record

Texas: Loya Insurance Company

In the Texas Department of Insurance’s complaint index dataset, Loya Insurance Company had 209 confirmed auto complaints on 163,131 policies in 2025, a complaint index of 7.78, up from 6.09 (117 complaints on 179,689 policies) in 2024. That is the third-highest raw complaint count in the Texas auto market, behind Progressive County Mutual (3.3 million policies) and Tesla Property & Casualty.

Adding the group’s two other Texas auto companies, Vision Insurance Company (20 complaints, index 10.30) and Young America Insurance Company (1 complaint), gives a combined 230 complaints on 187,100 policies, an index of 7.46 against the 2025 market average. One in every 11 confirmed auto complaints in Texas in 2025 was against a Loya Insurance Group company; the group held about 1.2% of policies.

Texas auto complaint index

Loya Insurance Group companies, 2024 vs 2025

0 3 6 9 12 6.09 7.78 Loya Insurance Co. 8.35 10.30 Vision Insurance Co. 6.22 7.46 Group combined 2024 2025
Complaint index = share of confirmed auto complaints ÷ share of auto policies; 1.00 is average. "Group combined" adds Loya Insurance Company, Vision Insurance Company and Young America Insurance Company and is our calculation. Source: Texas Department of Insurance, complaint indexes and policy counts, downloaded October 28, 2026.

California: Loya Casualty Insurance Company

California’s 2026 Consumer Complaint Study ranks Loya Casualty 45th of the 50 largest auto insurers, with 38 justified complaints in 2025 on about 213,756 exposures: 17.8 per 100,000. Its ratio has risen in each year of the study.

Regulator complaint data

Loya Casualty in California vs. the median of the 50 largest auto insurers

0 5 10 15 20 2.5 10.1 2023 3.5 15.7 2024 3.15 17.8 2025 Median of 50 Loya Casualty
Justified complaints closed per 100,000 exposures; the median is of the 50 insurers in the study for that year. Source: California Department of Insurance, 2026 Consumer Complaint Study, Auto.

For every insurer in both states, see our Texas car insurance complaint index and California car insurance complaint ratios.

Regulatory History

In June 2012, the Associated Press reported that Texas regulators fined Loya Insurance Co. $300,000 for unfair and deceptive business practices and said it had “failed to file accurate information on rates for its 210,000 drivers in Texas.” The company was ordered to provide details on how its rates and discounts are set.

Coverage, Service and Claims

Fred Loya’s core product is state-minimum liability coverage. Like most auto insurers, it can add physical damage coverage (collision and comprehensive) and other options; what is available and at what limits varies by state, so confirm on your quote.

  • Roadside assistance is available as a coverage: Fred Loya’s website gives a dedicated line, 1-855-548-5626, for customers who have its 24-hour roadside assistance coverage.
  • Claims are reported by phone at 1-800-880-0472; general service and quotes are at 1-800-444-4040 (both per its website).
  • In person. Its model is the storefront: many customers buy and pay at a local office.

Who Should Consider Fred Loya

Fred Loya can make sense if you:

  • Have been declined or priced out by standard carriers because of a DUI, accidents or a coverage lapse
  • Need an SR-22 filing and the cheapest legal policy (see what SR-22 insurance is)
  • Want to buy and pay in person near home

Before you do, compare it with other non-standard insurers. In the same Texas data, Dairyland County Mutual’s 2025 index was 0.41 and Infinity County Mutual’s 3.06; in California, Infinity Insurance Company’s ratio was 2.6. See our reviews of Dairyland, Infinity (Kemper Auto), National General and GoAuto. And if a standard-market carrier will still write you, check our best car insurance ranking and our guide to how much car insurance you need before settling for minimum limits.

FAQ

Is Fred Loya a good insurance company?

It is widely available and built for drivers who need low-cost minimum coverage, but its complaint record is weak. In Texas, Loya Insurance Company’s 2025 auto complaint index was 7.78, about eight times the market average for its size. In California, Loya Casualty Insurance Company’s 2025 ratio was 17.8 justified complaints per 100,000 exposures, against a median of 3.15 for the 50 largest auto insurers.

Who underwrites Fred Loya Insurance?

Fred Loya Insurance Agency sells policies issued by companies in the Loya Insurance Group. A California examination report names Loya Insurance Company, Vision Insurance Company and Young America Insurance Company as Texas-domiciled group companies, and says Loya Casualty Insurance Company’s California policies are produced solely by Fred Loya Insurance Agency through captive offices.

What states is Fred Loya in?

Fred Loya’s website lists Arizona, California, Colorado, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Texas, Indiana, Tennessee, Georgia, Illinois, Nevada, Alabama and Ohio, and says it has more than 800 offices, including offices in Walmart Supercenters in 10 states.

Does Fred Loya offer roadside assistance?

Yes, as an option. Fred Loya’s website gives a dedicated line, 1-855-548-5626, for customers who have its 24-hour roadside assistance coverage.

Alejandro Rioja

Alejandro Rioja

Founder & Lead Analyst · The Insurance Nerd

Alejandro has spent six years dismantling insurance jargon for everyday readers. He built the Nerd Score to give people a single, honest number they can actually trust — with the math published in full and not a dollar taken from the carriers it ranks.

Field Notes

One sharp insurance read, every Thursday.

The Nerd Desk newsletter: a single number, one carrier move worth knowing, and the fine print we caught this week. Free. No spam, ever.

UNSUBSCRIBE ANYTIME